I got a good laugh at Andrew Sullivan’s blog this morning (yes Virginia, he’s required reading):

“Gibson is not in the mainstream of Catholic thought; his emphasis on the Jewish priests in the Gospel narrative violates official Catholic concern about fomenting anti-Semitism. And his focus on the physical suffering of Christ may be excessive. … But I don’t trust Gibson an iota.”

Um, Andrew, near as I can tell, you yourself are not in the mainstream of Catholic thought, and when did you start to take notice of official Catholic concern? Andrew’s remarks are in response (support?) of sometimes contributor to National Review, Ed Kilgore, whose statements about Evangelical Christians bear little resemblance to the reality I know. Somehow, I don’t think he considers himself one. But he’s down right loopy in this sentence: 

“And third, I’m a bit concerned, though not surprised, by the sort of Popular Front thinking that has so many conservatives from every religious background expressing total solidarity with Gibson’s faith, which is by any standard a bit eccentric, and by Catholic standards specifically, heretical or at least schismatic. “

I don’t think any conservative are expressing total solidarity with Gibson’s faith – what I’ve heard is an expression of solidarity with his movie in so far as and so long as it is a faithful rendering of the Gospels. And perhaps Protestantism isn’t too worried about schisms – having been born in schism from the Catholic church, and further subdividing almost beyond counting subsequently. I think what heartens Christians, leaders and rank and file, is that here is a movie which unites all Christians, liberal and conservative; Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox: all Christians. Apparently though, not all we Christians are happy about that.

But then I hit Chris Johnson’s blog and had my perspective restored by his take on The Passion:

“Two thousand years on, many of us shake our heads in disgust at the fear and cowardice of Jesus’ inner circle who left Him alone at the end of His earthly life. We would be brave, we think; we would never desert our Lord. In a very small and indirect way, Mel Gibson is giving us a chance to stay with our Savior during His most terrible hours. And it’s interesting that lots of alleged Christians still prefer to run away.”

Thanks Chris.